- Fantasy Life Newsletter
- Posts
- š¤ Fantasy's Cheapest No. 1 WRs
š¤ Fantasy's Cheapest No. 1 WRs
Value hounds assemble!
114 days until Chiefs-Lions opening kickoffā¦
In todayās Fantasy Life Newsletter presented by Fantasy Lifeās Discord Server:
Five No. 1 WRs who are awfully cheap in fantasy land
Rankings vs. Underdog ADP: Biggest values and fades
More touches for Antonio Gibson!?
Team Preview Szn: Buffalo Bills
Itās 5/16. Take it away, Ian Hartitzā¦
Every day is a great day to fire up a best ball draft.
Underdog Fantasy has contests of all shapes and sizes to enter, and some of the early average draft position (ADP) data is intriguing when it comes to WRs potentially being slept on.
Overall, just six receivers are their own teamās highest-ranked player at the position, yet they find themselves outside fantasyās top-36 WRs at the moment.
A scholar and/or whatever edition of ChatGPT is out these days might describe these players as āfantasy footballās cheapest No. 1 WRs.ā
* Law and Order intro *
These are their stories.
šŖ Titans WR Treylon Burks (ADP: WR38, pick 76.3)
The allure of Burks is simple: He flashed down the stretch and remains the clear-cut No. 1 WR inside an offense with arguably less target competition than any other unit in the league. Itās rare to find a first-round WR with sky-high target share potential available this late in drafts.
Yes, the Titans remain fully devoted to the religion of giving Derrick Henry as many touches as possible.
Also, yes, Burks is currently going in a good range of drafts where there are only a few other WRs with his sort of upside still available; heās a great third or fourth WR addition to squads deploying a zero-RB-esque strategy.
š» Ravens WR Zay Flowers (ADP: WR44, pick 89.5)
Thereās a lot to like about Flowers as a prospect. Right now, Flowers, Odell Beckham Jr., and Rashod Bateman are going within 20 picks of each other.
Nobody is doubting the ability of Flowers to rise to the top of the group; just realize the Ravens havenāt exactly been great at enabling fantasy-friendly WRs over the years.
Top scoring Ravens WR in fantasy PPR points per game (min 8 games):
2018: John Brown (WR56)
2019: Marquise Brown (WR48)
2020: Brown (WR43)
2021: Brown (WR23)
2022: Devin Duvernay (WR61), Rashod Bateman (WR56) if you go with a minimum of six gamesā Ian Hartitz (@Ihartitz)
2:30 PM ā¢ Apr 10, 2023
šŗ Patriots WR JuJu Smith-Schuster (ADP: WR50, pick 107.5)
Give the tik-toker credit for rebounding with a 78-933-3 receiving line with the Chiefs in 2022; his 9.2 yards per target were the most he has averaged since his rookie season.
Most impressive was JuJu's ability after the catch: He ranked seventh among 80 qualified WRs in yards after the catch per reception (5.9) during his first season in Kansas City and the production wasnāt overly fluky as evidenced by his sixth-place ranking in yards after the catch above expectation (Next-Gen Stats).
Smith-Schuster is still just 26 years old and once again finds himself in an offense with few other proven avenues to go with the football.
Of course, a big season is contingent on OC Bill O'Brien 1.) getting Mac Jones to look more like the guy we saw in 2021 vs. 2022, and 2.) Making life a bit more fantasy-friendly for a Patriots WR group that ranks 28th in expected PPR points over the past three seasons.
š Panthers WR Jonathan Mingo (ADP: WR58, pick 128)
The Panthers are the right sort of situation for the talented rookie to ball out from day one. While itās possible D.J. Chark, Adam Thielen, and Terrace Marshall earn the Week 1 starting nods, Mingo is reportedly already forming a strong connection with Bryce Young and could see his ADP (continue) to rise as this uncertain depth chart reveals itself.
The Panthers are a top-six offense in terms of available targets and air yards; Mingo arguably has less 2023 target competition than any rookie WR.
Read on for more on Mingo below.
šØ Giants WR Jalin Hyatt (ADP: WR61, pick 140.1)
This is easily one of the NFLās top-five cheapest WR rooms.
Highest/lowest average ADP from every team's top-three WRs.
Most expensive:
1. Bengals (50.5 average ADP)
2. Seahawks (52.8)
3. Chargers (63.3)
4. Vikings (72.1)
5. Jaguars (73.4)
...
28. Falcons (160)
29. Giants (163.3)
30. Titans (169.6)
31. Patriots (171.8)
32. Texans (184.5)ā Ian Hartitz (@Ihartitz)
6:12 PM ā¢ May 5, 2023
Itās tough to overly criticize Hyattās standing at the top of this muddled mess considering the rookieās field-stretching skill set stands out in this slot-filled WR room; itād be rather shocking if he doesnāt find a way into three-WR sets sooner rather than later.
Of course, being the primary deep-ball threat in an offense that posted the leagueās third-lowest aDOT is like having the best raincoat in Nevada; Hyattās rather steep learning curve coming out of the wide-open Tennessee offense could prevent him from seizing too high of a target share inside of a passing game that was reluctant to overly feature any single WR last season.
Identifying major differences in rankings vs. average draft positions (ADP) is the easiest way to land yourself some value in fantasy drafts of all shapes and sizes. Chris Allen has you covered with some of Fantasy Lifeās most-extreme discrepancies at the moment.
Drafting a team can feel daunting if youāre new to best ball.
Youāve got sickos throwing out strategy tips and folks arguing about Week 17 correlations. But the draft itself is also problematic. Youāll have a plan and then watch another manager draft your guy. And the backup options by ADP arenāt worth the click.
There should be a process for finding value independent of the market.
Enter Dwainās Top 150 ranks.
With these, I found a few players worth reaching for and others to avoid as the hot best ball summer quickly approaches.
š Value Targets
šÆ WR Jonathan Mingo ā Panthers
Dwainās Rank: 142nd
Underdog ADP: 129.1
Letās set aside the obvious for a second. At 6ā1ā-226 lbs with 4.46 speed, Jonathan Mingo steps onto the Panthers squad as the most athletic receiving option for Bryce Young.
Head coach Frank Reichās plan for deploying Mingo makes me more interested than focusing on his measurables.
Frank Reich's vision for WR Jonathan Mingo
Shallows. Crossers. Vertical routes. Ball skills.
Repeated multiple times how great of a fit he is in their offensive plan.
ā Josh Norris (@JoshNorris)
7:30 PM ā¢ Apr 29, 2023
The Panthers want the Ole Miss phenom to function as a short-intermediate option. And, compared to receivers drafted ahead of Mingo, Carolinaās decision makes sense.

Mingoās after-the-catch averages and efficiency per route on short and intermediate targets align with his peers. So, without much competition in front of Mingo, drafters would be prudent to place bets on his takeover of the Panthersā offense during his rookie campaign.
š RB Elijah Mitchell ā 49ers
Dwainās Rank: 120th
Underdog ADP: 127.2
For Elijah Mitchell to be a value, you have to split his cost into two components: health and workload. And the market has appropriately priced his health.
Fantasy pundits assumed that Christian McCaffrey would take over the backfield without mentioning Mitchell. CMCās knack for evading tackles and earning targets would wipe away any residual value for the remaining SF RBs.
Mitchell had other thoughts.

The two played in three competitive games and nearly split the workload. Even if you included targets, Mitchell had more high-value touches than McCaffrey. Granted, itās a small sample size, but it indicates how Kyle Shanahan intended to deploy the duo.
CMC only had two more carries than Mitchell in the playoffs during their two games together. And yet, McCaffrey enters ā23 as the RB1 while his 1B sits at RB41. With San Franciscoās PROE likely to stay in the bottom 12, Mitchell should be a target at his current price.
Run, don't walk, to take advantage of these ADPs on Underdog Fantasy with a 100% deposit match of up to $100 by creating a new account below!
PS, everyone needs more fantasy value. (Donāt fight it)
āļø It's Time To Start Drafting Your Best Ball Teams
Peter Overzet is here to help you successfully navigate the start of Best Ball season...
The big tournaments are open and the best ball streets are buzzing, but how do you perfect your early-season drafting?!
Join his office hours in the Fantasy Life Discord at 3:30 PM ET TODAY to get your pressing best ball strategy questions answered directly by an industry leader, including...
Early-offseason ADP discounts
Which rookies to target
Early-round QBs vs late-round QBs
ā¦and anything else that may be on your mind, all for FREE.
Just make sure to avoid any questions about mulching your yard.
š Quite the fashion statement from one of the NFLās best QBs. Joe Brrr strikes again.
š If you could choose one player to have an injury-free career, who would it be? Fun replies here.
š The Falcons plan on using the 2023 NFL Draftās No. 8 overall pick all over the field. Let Bijan cook?
š¦¶ Incredible individual performance in the USFL. Who needs a kicker?
š„ Injuries objectively suck. At least this rookie RB says heās healthy.
āļø You know there are problems when the Twitter bio gets changed. Drama with the Jets.
š Could this FINALLY be the year Antonio Gibson gets fed? Happy offseason coach speak szn.
š¤ Matt Ryan has an update on his future. No, heās not retiring just yet.
šŗ Streaming services are taking over. Major W for Peacock.
Fantasy Life senior analyst Ian Hartitz is breaking down all 32 NFL teams over the next two months. Letās take a look at the Bills, who once again profile as having one of the leagueās most fantasy-friendly passing attacksā¦
š WRs
Stefon Diggs (Ianās WR4)
Gabriel Davis (WR39)
Khalil Shakir (WR86)
Deonte Harty (WR87)
Diggs has peeled off 127-1535-8, 103-1225-10 and 108-1429-11 receiving lines since teaming up with Josh Allen in 2020. Only Davante Adams, Cooper Kupp, Tyreek Hill and Justin Jefferson have averaged more PPR points per game during this span.
Of course, father time is undefeated, and Diggs turns 30 in November. This is historically when WRs go from great to good in fantasy land: Only 14 WRs have posted top-12 seasons in PPR points per game after turning 30 over the past 10 years.
And yet, nothing about Diggsā 2022 performance indicated a major dropoff in performance was imminent and the Bills didnāt really add any target competition to worry about. Age alone isnāt enough reason to completely fade somebody; just realize itās enough to serve as a tie-breaker when compared against similarly elite talents with absurdly fantasy-friendly volume.
The longtime stud remains plenty capable of twisting up cornerbacks of all shapes and sizes; you donāt need more than one hand to count the number of WRs you should pick ahead of him in fantasy land.
And then thereās Davis, whose season-long 48-836-7 receiving line wasnāt exactly what truthers had in mind considering the man ended his 2021 campaign with an incredible 8-201-4 performance in the Billsā batshit crazy AFC Divisional Round loss to the Chiefs. His status as the WR38 in PPR points per game didnāt exactly pay off his pricey WR24 preseason ADP.
One important note: Davis suffered a high-ankle sprain in a Week 2 practice that he ultimately played through during the rest of the season. He still managed to post the occasional boom, but the injury helps explain why the team felt the need to re-sign Smokey and Beasley later in the season.
Bills GM Brandon Beane certainly seems to be giving Davis the benefit of the doubt.
āI have a lot of confidence with Gabe [Davis] as our No. 2 [wide receiver]ā
Brandon Beane
ā Dan Fetes (@danfetes)
3:52 PM ā¢ Feb 28, 2023
Somehow still only 24 years of age, Davis (again) profiles as Allenās rather undisputed No. 2 WR. The Billsā pass-happy offense has produced the single-most expected WR PPR points per game over the past three seasons; improved health in 2023 should yield returns closer to what drafters were hoping for last season.
Or maybe it wonāt; either way, Davis is currently being priced below where he finished last season. The definition of buying a fantasy asset closer to their floor than ceiling, Davis is a prime post-hype candidate who has proven capable of booming in a major way when everything is right.
Iām largely out on the rest of the Bills receivers as anything other than LATE round darts. This is mostly due to the insertion of the teamās first-round TE Dalton Kincaid. More on him ā¦ right now!
Looking for more discussion on the Bills? Check out Ian Hartitz & Dwain McFarland on the Fantasy Life Podcast!